So, with a lot of help from Michael (thanks Michael), here is the current plan for the expansion draft, when we go from 12 teams to 16 this offseason. I’ve done some testing, and this seems like it will work. I’m posting it for comments, questions, and hopefully for some kind of approval by the league. Nate, Michael, and I are on board with it. But, this is obviously a big deal and we want to make sure this is acceptable, or at least won’t cause any riots.
—————————————————-
1. The expansion draft will occur as soon as the offseason starts (i.e., after the 2009 playoffs finish and budgets are set, but before arbitration and free agency). We will use the game’s built-in expansion draft feature.
2. The expansion draft pool will consist of all players in the existing teams’ organizations. This includes players on the major league squad, on any minor league team, players on the disabled list, players on waivers or DFA lists, players drafted this year, etc. No player will be automatically protected from the expansion draft.
3. Each existing team will be allowed to protect 20 players in their organization. This includes all major leaguers, minor leaguers, players on the disabled list, etc.
4. The four new teams will each select 24 players, using a “snake” draft order (1-2-3-4-4-3-2-1, etc.).
5. With 96 players being drafted, each existing team will lose eight players on average. In the draft, existing teams will not be allowed to lose no more than eleven players each. After 11 players are picked from one organization, their remaining players are all protected from the draft.
6. There are no other “pullbacks”. In other words, after a player is selected from an existing team, the existing team does not get to protect any additional players.
7. Because the game’s expansion draft seems to be set automatically at 35 rounds long, we need to have 11 more players drafted by each new team just to finish out the draft. Therefore, each existing team will also submit a list of four players with minor league contracts that they don’t care about losing and the commissioners will use this pool of 48 players to finish out the draft.
8. After the draft is finished, the new teams will have their minor league affiliates’ rosters automatically filled with newly created players.
9. Because popular players lost in the expansion draft cause a loss of fan interest, we will use SuperCommissioner (TM) powers to restore all existing teams to their pre-draft fan interest levels. The new teams will, however, keep any fan interest bump they get.
—————————————————-
A couple words of explanation.
FYI, Michael and I came to 20 as the number to protect after concluding that it would be fair to protect 12-13 in a major league draft and 7-8 in a minor league draft. To give owners maximum flexibility, we combined the two portions into one draft. Based on our review of the various teams, 20 is a number where deep teams will lose good players, but less talented teams will be able to protect their really key guys. The expansion teams will get at least some quality talent, but won’t be raiding all of the existing teams’ rosters. (We also came up with the number of 24 players to be drafted per new team because we first came up with 15 major leaguers and 9 minor leaguers.)
Also FYI, the game’s expansion draft feature doesn’t allow pullbacks, which is one reason we’re not proposing them. The game’s draft doesn’t allow a limit on the maximum number of players to be drafted, so it will have to be imposed from on high using SuperCommissioner(TM) powers.
A big part of the problem is that auto-filling the new teams’ minor league rosters proved to be a TERRIBLE way to get them some talent. Also, if you auto-fill the major league rosters, there are all kinds of different problems, starting with the fact that none of the newly created players have contracts. It’s a mess.
So, thoughts, concerns, questions, complaints, quibbles?
P.S. Before people complain that their roster will be unfairly pillaged in this form of draft, keep in mind that my Pittsburgh Pisces will lose as much or more talent than anyone else. And Nate won’t be too far behind. If you still think it’s unfair, go ahead and say so. But we didn’t arrive at these numbers to be punitive. We just want the new teams to at least start out with some talent and have a fighting chance of not sucking for five years.
Recent Comments